Welcome, Guest   [ Yahoo! Sports | Message Boards home | Sign in ]
Message Boards
   

Sport Message Boards

Newcastle Knights

Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever?

Messages: Sorting:
<< Previous page | 1 2 3 4 5 | Next page >>
Author/Date Message

By: whatsdoing23
15/08/2007
6:31 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  whatsdoing23

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
I didn't know five-year olds could get arthritis.

By: statsy_aus
15/08/2007
4:45 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  statsy_aus

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
it took you 4 mins to double post? did the arthritis get in the way of pushing post.

By: cristan2832
15/08/2007
4:20 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  cristan2832

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
I think Brian smith is doing a good job an im a knights supporter. For to long the club have let good players go and kept mediocre players to keep joey and bedsy. In 2000 we should have won the comp but went on to win it the next year. No thanks to M hagan that was set up by W ryan. Smith has left every club in a better position than when first arrived and has taken every club to a grand final ecpt norths. We need better players and that is wot he is doing building for the future. Players get payed enough abd have played for long enough to know what to expct week in week out so they should suck it up. Funny how smith took parra 2 1 week from the gf and got smashed by the cowboys and then the team come out the next year with doubt and got smashed. Have to put faith in wot he is doing cause no other coach would do it.

By: cristan2832
15/08/2007
4:16 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  cristan2832

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
I think Brian smith is doing a good job an im a nights supporter. For to long the club have let good players go and kept mediocre players to keep joey and bedsy. In 2000 we should have won the comp but went on to win it the next year. No thanks to M hagan that was set up by W ryan. Smith has left every club in a better position than when first arrived and has taken every club to a grand final ecpt norths. We need better players and that is wot he is doing building for the future. Players get payed enough abd have played for long enough to know what to expct week in week out so they should suck it up. Funny how smith took parra 2 1 week from the gf and got smashed by the cowboys and then the team come out the next year with doubt and got smashed. Have to put faith in wot he is doing cause no other coach would do it.

By: rachmorrell
14/08/2007
4:54 pm

Message deleted. Reason: Potentially defamatory

By: whatsdoing23
12/08/2007
1:04 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  whatsdoing23

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
Brian Smith to coach the Sharks next year then opmmul?

By: opmmul
12/08/2007
12:53 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  opmmul

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
If Wayne Bennett was coaching Newcastle the results would be the same.For too long the Newcastle players had relied on Andrew Johns to get them out of trouble.One just has to look at their win/loss record when he was out injured.Those players who have left or won't be there next year had plenty of chances to prove themselves when Andrew Johns was out injured but they failed to do so.

By: whatsdoing23
12/08/2007
11:53 am

Yahoo! Profile:
  whatsdoing23

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
So they're playing only for the money?

By: what_the_fack
12/08/2007
11:51 am

Yahoo! Profile:
  what_the_fack

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
They are paid to perform no matter what.
If you go to see U2 and they have had a bust up with their management and put in a very poor performance you are entitled to ask for your money back.
Whether the players know it or not, football is now part of the entertainment business. And fans and sponsors pay good money to see them play to the best of their ability.
Not for players to cry off because the coach has said harsh words to them.

By: whatsdoing23
12/08/2007
11:43 am

Yahoo! Profile:
  whatsdoing23

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
I agree, the players weren't putting in a full efort up until Fittler became coach. Is it a fair assumption then, that the new coach is getting the best out of his players?

You perform better when you have a good reason to perform. Yes, the fear of the axe can be a decent motivator, but I reckon for most players, they perform better when they respect the coach, and the coach respects them.

By: what_the_fack
12/08/2007
11:34 am

Yahoo! Profile:
  what_the_fack

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
How does a team get smacked 56-0 one week go out and win 4 and draw 1 out of their next 5.
If you are suggesting it was any great coaching from Fittler, you should think a little deeper.
The players werent trying, for whatever reason.
Maybe they didnt like Anderson's coaching methods, but blind freddie could see that the players werent having a red hot go up until Fittler arrived.
The same goes for Newcastle, if the players stop whining and got on with playing they might be higher up the later.

By: whatsdoing23
12/08/2007
11:06 am

Yahoo! Profile:
  whatsdoing23

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
Hang on...the Roosters got a new coach and started winning...and it was the players fault they were losing before? How does that make any sense at all? You do say some strange things.

Of course you're allowed to disagree with me, that's my point. I'm not the one who said "You can't blame Smith for the losses".

By: what_the_fack
12/08/2007
11:00 am

Yahoo! Profile:
  what_the_fack

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
In a democracy I also have the right to disagree with your point of view. As friday says the coach can only do so much, once the players are on the field it is up to them.
Perfect case is the roosters, get a new coach and are undeafeted in 5 games.
Obviously those players werent give 100% up to that point.
And were letting down the club and its supporters.

By: fridayfooty
12/08/2007
9:17 am

Yahoo! Profile:
  fridayfooty

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
The thing i want to know is Why do the coaches get the blames when the players are the ones that stuff up not the coach the coach is given the job of trying to teach the player ball skills,tackling skills,and to get them conditioned as well as giving them a game plan but when the players are stupid show ponies the coach gets the blame and i for 1 am sick of it.

By: whatsdoing23
12/08/2007
8:44 am

Yahoo! Profile:
  whatsdoing23

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
Why can't I blame Smith for their losses? I should be allowed to blame whoever I want. We do still live in a democracy, right?

Newcastle were going alright at the start of the season without Johns. So what happened since then?

By: what_the_fack
12/08/2007
2:51 am

Message deleted. Reason: Profanity

By: natasha100178
10/08/2007
4:29 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  natasha100178

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
YES HE IS!!!!!

Look at what he has done this year and to parramatta last year

BRIAN SMITH SHOULD BE GOOOOOOOONEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE E

By: statsy_aus
10/08/2007
2:21 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  statsy_aus

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
Fatty was given a mandate by the Ch9 board......try and be more of an embarrassment than Sam Newman. He hasn't done it yet, but he tries every week. And i think that is what counts.

By: whatsdoing23
10/08/2007
12:04 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  whatsdoing23

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
Sad but true. One thing is certain at the moment - Smith has the full support of the board.

I watched the Footy Show blokes talking about this last night - they really have no clue. Fatty should quit and stop embarassing himself. He does seem to enjoy doing so, unfortunately.

By: statsy_aus
10/08/2007
11:29 am

Yahoo! Profile:
  statsy_aus

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
Brian Smith will NOT be sacked this season. When the board gives you a mandate (no not what quacks proffession is) to clear out and build, then they have to stand by him. However if he hasn't got any results by round 10 next year......gooooooone!

By: whatsdoing23
10/08/2007
6:56 am

Yahoo! Profile:
  whatsdoing23

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
The way the situation is headed, that might just happen!

By: what_the_fack
10/08/2007
12:33 am

Yahoo! Profile:
  what_the_fack

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
Players should play and let coaches coach.
If they want to be management they should retire and take up positions on the board.

By: statsy_aus
9/08/2007
9:16 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  statsy_aus

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
No worries mate.

By: whatsdoing23
9/08/2007
7:21 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  whatsdoing23

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
Never mind stats, found three separate stories on foxsports...

By: statsy_aus
9/08/2007
9:16 am

Yahoo! Profile:
  statsy_aus

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:Is Brian Smith the worst coach ever? Reply to this message
Sorry saw it sports tonight last night....i will see if i can find something on it for you.
<< Previous page | 1 2 3 4 5 | Next page >>



Copyright © 2008 Yahoo! Pty Limited. All rights reserved.
Advertise with Us - Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Help