Welcome, Guest   [ Yahoo! Sports | Message Boards home | Sign in ]
Message Boards
   

Sport Message Boards

Adelaide Crows

NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SACKED

Messages: Sorting:
<< Previous page | 1 2 3 | Next page >>
Author/Date Message

By: xanthyac
14/09/2009
4:30 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  xanthyac

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
Tyson Edwards is a legend and Neil Craig has been responsible for the crows doing as well as they did. Better luck next year boys, you did a lot better than was predicted at season start when the so called people in the know had you finishing 9th and power in the 8.

By: gonefishin_67@y7mail.com
6/09/2009
5:17 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  gonefishin_67@y7mail.com

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
tyson edwards does nto need to retire he is one of their best players adelaide crows a powerhouse these days and neil craig is a big part of that

By: youareachooch@ymail.com
17/08/2009
4:06 am

Yahoo! Profile:
  youareachooch@ymail.com

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
these two dogs have to go ,i cant stand them ,reid has got black teeth ,craig needs a hair colour

By: moon_juicy
28/06/2009
5:50 am

Message deleted. Reason: Breach of terms of service

By: reddog.1957
26/06/2009
12:47 am

Yahoo! Profile:
  reddog.1957

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
even on the olympic threads 9 mths too late lolol

By: orrightfella
17/06/2009
4:42 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  orrightfella

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
41 possessions in his 300th. Geez if he gets slower, maybe he'll only get 30 as his high. He'll be 80+ have dementia and still be faster than you ever were brownose.

Needing to deflect from your clubs failure brownose you're trolling everywhere else to try and hide. Hope your courage to face up to things isn't a trait from your parents.

By: rbrownoz
17/06/2009
4:24 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  rbrownoz

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
tyson edwards should retire too,he is getting slow

By: orrightfella
2/06/2009
12:43 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  orrightfella

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
Reid is retiring at the end of the season jeffrey.

By: jeffreyrstrikesback
31/05/2009
3:03 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  jeffreyrstrikesback

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
have the crows fallen asleep or what...

what is going on?

after such a great start, thus far in the third quarter,
they've not scored.

the hawks are playing so pathetic today they have failed to get back into the game.

By: jeffreyrstrikesback
31/05/2009
2:23 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  jeffreyrstrikesback

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
not today they don't. Crows are cruising against the pathetic Hawks. I'd say Craigy and Reid's jobs are safe at least for the end of the season. So let's freeze this thread for now.

By: likedaweed
20/05/2009
5:20 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  likedaweed

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
craig was appointed because he was going to build a team hes used the same players for the last 4 years just so he could have a good win loss % Most of the players hes brought in are average and he still relies on the old boys he dont have much idea hes a good assistant coach but poor as a head coach

By: orrightfella
20/05/2009
12:56 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  orrightfella

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
In 2005 we would have beaten St Kilda with Riccuito on board. His suspension cost us being on the same side of the draw with our bunnies Sydney. we still would have had to face West Coast in the GF and they had our measure. A younger quicker midfield in Judd Kerr and Cousins was always going to outdo McLeod, Edwards and Goodwin. The Crows went as far as they could in those years (still with no forward as good as even Lynch upfront for WC) because of the players they had.

By: adrianshere
19/05/2009
9:05 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  adrianshere

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
What i couldn't believe was at 3/4 time v lions ben hart was interviewed as he was coming off the ground and he told the interviewer "our aim is just to win the last quarter"

????????????? WTF. No doubt he would have got that from that insipid coach craig..

So, we have totally given in by that statement..

We were so ripe in 05 and 06 but he totally farked that up by bewildering coaching in finals...


get rid of him as the excuses have long fell on deaf ears.

By: orrightfella
19/05/2009
2:10 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  orrightfella

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
... had to take it's toll somewhere along the line.

So this is where the Crows are at. In spite of the club saying the final 8 this year is the first goal and they will always have high expectations reality needs to set in amongst some supporters and they need to know that the 8 looks out of reach this year and we can build next year towards what should be something in 2011/12.

Can people wait that long after the wastage of the Shaw years, 5 years of almost but not quite by Ayres who gave us no future but relied on Roo, Macca, Goody and Edwards. And Craig who took his best shot with an ageing Roo, Macca etc but fell to eventual champs and runners up the Eagles. And when he got past that decided only a new generation would get the Crows there again.

I think we just have to wait. Anyone who beleives there is a second coming or a new messiah is just plain deluded imo.

By: orrightfella
19/05/2009
2:02 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  orrightfella

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
I think the clubs are working in the right direction without bottoming out for draft choices. Mind you they have failed with their first picks with Meesen, Angwin and Gilligan being the worst in my memory at this point.There maybe others and I'm sure someone will point them out.

Anyway I look from line to line starting witht he ruck and see Maric 23/34 (age/games), Griffin 23/30, Moran 22/12 (ok I was harsh with him calling him the AFL's worst player, anger gets you sometimes) and Tippett 22/27. The middle consists of Edwards 32/297, Thompson 26/139,Reilly 25/101, Van Berlo 23/84, Symes 24/40, Vince 23/39, Knights 22/54,Douglas 22/46, Mackay 21/27. The backs Rutten 26/110, Johncok 26/154, Otten 20/10 , McLeod 32/312, Bock 26/91, Goodwin 32/246. Forwards, Petrenko 19/8, Walker 19/8, Stevens 27/108, Tippett 22/27, Porplyzia 24/52, Dangerfield 19/10.
Dangerfield, Walker, Otten and Petrenko are practically first year players, Mackay, Tippett and Moran are second year players whilst Griffin, Maric, Douglas, Vince and Symes havent 50 games under their belts and Porplyzia and Knights have just over 50.

This is a developing side and young fellas make mistakes more often and dont have the mental or physical motor of their more experienced counterparts. People can point to other sides with players that are young like Jack Ziebell at North but how many Jack Ziebells are there running around?

I was a strident critic of Neil Craig when he first got the job and I said here he would not take the Crows to a flag. But I'm going to have faith in him and the players now because I can see rewards long term if they keep at it and the improvement continues which in most cases it has.

When you are so used to having your side play well or win most weeks the losing and lack of good play gets to you if you look for instant gratification and not the long term. You cant win always and losing the experience the Crows have over the last 3 years so they can build for the future

By: likedaweed
18/05/2009
9:23 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  likedaweed

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
hes to smart for his own good craig

By: hillg30
16/05/2009
9:30 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  hillg30

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
Anyone watching the crows has to understand that craig and that old fool from cycling have to get out .walsh is a goose and craig dosnt know how to turn things around when they need to.

By: sonny_harlow
11/05/2009
11:00 am

Yahoo! Profile:
  sonny_harlow

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
what do you expect the crows to achieve this year. The list isnt that strong.
we havent had a target forward since Modra. Taylor Walker is still young, as is alot of the devloping list.

I think the crows could learn alot from the bombers. They will lose their fair share of games, but atleast they are playing exciting football.
Im getting pretty tired of this stagnent defensive style of play.
We are struggling to kick 100+ points a match.

By: slly_willis
10/05/2009
7:38 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  slly_willis

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
Just to let you know Neil Craig has the highest win loss ratio out of all current coaches!

By: adrianshere
10/05/2009
6:24 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  adrianshere

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
I been sayin that for ages as you know smokin..

I farken hate him.

By: smokinbourbon
10/05/2009
5:01 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  smokinbourbon

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
wow ..hate bring up an old thread..but 12 months later it still appropriated....NEIL CRAIG needs to go... his game plan is fkn useless and he still has no plan B...what do u know..nothing fkn changed... NIEL CRAIG is just a black spot on the adelaide footy club and it time to remove it!!!

By: bigsalami29
29/11/2008
8:05 am

Message deleted. Reason: Breach of terms of service

By: scotty_1960
14/11/2008
9:55 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  scotty_1960

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
Totally agree! They've being going nowhere fast since Craig has had them. Time for some new Blood at the Top!!

By: oddielokie
16/09/2008
11:05 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  oddielokie

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
wake up adrian....its 2008 not 1966 , the game has changed , its evolving , as it should . we lost round 1 and if we played all out attack we would lose just about every week. look at essendon and carlton , all attack very little defense , did they make the finals? geelong ...great defense all over the ground , hawthorn the same , sydney won a premership with all out defense and very little attack. if your not happy with the way footy is being played these days then maybe you should find a different sport to follow.

By: siradriancrowsrock57
16/09/2008
5:34 pm

Yahoo! Profile:
  siradriancrowsrock57

Did this message offend you?
  Sign in to report abuse

Re:NEIL CRAIG & JOHN REID NEED TO BE SAC ... Reply to this message
well you 3 keep supporting his negative game plan

if he was to tell the guys "go full steam ahead and take risks" then i would be happier.
win, lose or draw like we did in rd 1 against the dogs

that was a cracker and was just happy to see a positive game even tho we just fell short.
but then just about every game from then on was far less positive and we lost many of those by being too defensive

if we lose lets lose with all guns blazing.
<< Previous page | 1 2 3 | Next page >>



Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Pty Limited. All rights reserved.
Advertise with Us - Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Help